Write a better performance review with AI
By Mary Noble-Tolla ·
Before You Start
Goal: Use dedicated time with your Circle to learn how to find your biggest achievements with AI, quantify them, and write them into a draft of your self-review.
Optional prep before the meeting (10 mins):
You can do this guide without any prep, but connecting or uploading your work to your AI tool beforehand helps make the meeting more efficient.
Open the AI tool you use most often and connect or upload what you can from the list below. Use an AI tool your company approves, and check your company's policy before you upload confidential documents or data.
Sources to upload or connect to AI
- Your last performance review and self-review
- Your job description and the criteria for the next level
- Your goals or OKRs for the year
- Project documents, decks, and status updates
- Meeting notes and task lists
- Your calendar, so AI can see your major projects and meetings
- Your email, chats, and messages, including thanks and feedback from colleagues, clients, and your manager
- Data that quantifies your impact, such as Tableau dashboards and Excel or Google Sheets files
- Your company's performance review form or template
- The three outcomes that matter most to your manager
Bring your laptop to the meeting.
Meeting Agenda · Approx. 60 mins
- Member Updates · 10 mins
- Icebreaker · 10 mins
- Key Takeaways · 5 mins
- Activities · 20 mins
- One Action · 10 mins
- Wrap-Up · 5 mins
Member Updates · 10 mins
Go around your Circle and share personal updates. Keep them brief and focused on significant changes or important decisions since the last time you met. It's OK not to have one every month. If you have a One Action update from last time, share that too.
Icebreaker · 10 mins
Invite everyone in the group to share. Keep answers to one or two minutes per person.
Think back over the last year. What's one piece of positive feedback from a colleague, client, or manager that you still remember, and what was it about?
Key Takeaways · 5 mins
- Start with your manager's priorities — Lead your self-review with your achievements that connect to your manager's top priorities and goals.
- Look beyond your memory — Your email, documents, and chat history hold achievements and positive feedback you've forgotten. AI can search them in minutes.
- Quantify your impact and say what you led — Add numbers such as revenue influenced, problems solved, metrics moved, or time saved. Spell out which parts you were responsible for.
- Check every detail before you use it — Verify numbers, dates, and credit against your own records before you use anything an AI tool writes.
Activity 1 · 10 mins
Find and Quantify Your Achievements with AI
Work quietly (5 mins)
If you haven't already done so, connect or upload as much as you can from the list of Sources above.
Then, paste this prompt into your AI tool:
Look through everything I've shared, our chat history, and my email from the last twelve months. Find my top achievements. For each one, tell me what I did, results, and any feedback I received from colleagues, clients, or my manager, including who said it and when. Add numbers that show the impact, using the data I've shared: revenue, time saved, growth, volume, quality, or other measures. Then ask me which parts of each achievement I personally led, and separate what I led from what the team achieved. Only include what you can find in my materials, and flag anything you're unsure about or that still needs a number.
Share out loud in pairs or trios (5 mins)
Take turns sharing. Each person answers one or more of these:
- Which achievement are you proudest of from the past year, and did AI find it for you?
- What did AI find that you'd forgotten about?
- What else could you tell the AI to make its answer better?
Activity 2 · 10 mins
Write Your Self-Review with AI
Work quietly (5 mins)
Paste the prompt below into your AI tool. For tips on getting higher-quality writing from AI, see How to enhance your writing with AI.
Using the achievements we just built and my company's performance review template, draft my self-review. Lead with the achievements that connect most directly to my manager's top priorities. Frame each contribution around team and business impact, like this: "I drove X, which helped the team achieve Y." Use only facts and numbers from my materials. Keep the tone direct and confident, and don't downplay my contributions.
If you're planning to ask for a promotion, add this to the prompt:
I'm planning to ask for a promotion. Open the self-review with a short paragraph that includes this request: "I want to take on more responsibility so I can have a bigger impact on [team goal]. Would you consider advancing me to the next level?" Fill in [team goal] using my manager's top priorities. Then present each achievement as evidence for why I'm ready for the next level.
Then skim your draft and pick what you think is its strongest line.
Highlight reel in pairs or trios (5 mins)
Each person reads their strongest self-review line aloud. The others cheer them on.
Optional take-home practice: Ask your AI tool to draft a warm note to your peer reviewers with the projects you'd like them to comment on. Then ask it to suggest questions you can ask in your review conversation, including what to ask if the feedback you receive is vague.
One Action · 10 mins
Commit to one concrete action — big or small — you'll take before next meeting. Go around the Circle and share (1 minute or less per member). Vocalizing it helps hold each other accountable.
Finish your self-review draft and check all numbers against your own records. Come back ready to share how it went.
Wrap-Up · 5 mins
Before you break, plan your next meeting and close on an energetic note. Go around your Circle one by one and finish the sentence:
Now I am feeling… (choose one word).
- Set the day, time, and location
- Choose the next topic or resource
- Confirm who's leading the discussion
- Decide how you'll stay in touch in between