How to give hard feedback that people hear and act on
By Mary Noble-Tolla ·
Before you start
Goal: Learn a four-part formula for giving difficult feedback from cognitive psychologist LeeAnn Renninger, write a script for a real conversation, and practice staying clear and calm if the other person gets defensive, so you can speak up with confidence and give people a better chance to hear and act on your feedback.
Watch: Members are encouraged to watch the video beforehand, but a quick recap at the meeting works too.
Meeting agenda · Approx. 60 mins
- Member Updates · 10 mins
- Icebreaker · 10 mins
- Key takeaways · 5 mins
- Activities · 25 mins
- One Action · 5 mins
- Wrap-Up · 5 mins
Member updates · 10 mins
Go around your Circle and share personal updates. Keep them brief and focused on significant changes or important decisions since the last time you met. It's OK not to have one every month. If you have a One Action update from last time, share that too.
Icebreaker · 10 mins
Invite everyone in the group to share. Keep answers to one or two minutes per person.
Think of a time when you were hesitant to give hard feedback. What made you hesitate? Did you give the feedback anyway, and if you did, how did it go?
Key takeaways · 5 mins
Read the takeaways aloud, taking turns. Each person reads one.
- Aim for clear and calm — Feedback that's too soft often isn't recognized as feedback, and feedback that's too direct tends to trigger defensiveness. Stick to what you saw or heard, and keep your tone even.
- Ask permission before you start — Open with a short yes-or-no question, such as "Do you have five minutes to talk about how that last conversation went?" It tells the other person feedback is coming and gives them a say in the timing.
- Use facts and impact, not labels — Skip words like "unreliable" or "proactive," which mean different things to different people. Say "You said you'd get that email to me by 11, and I still don't have it. Because of that, I couldn't move forward on my work."
- Listen to defuse defensiveness — You're more likely to be heard when you listen with respect. End with a question like "How do you see it?" and repeat back what you heard.
- Agree on a next step — Work together to identify concrete actions to address the issue. When people have a say in the solution, they're more likely to follow through.
- Ask for feedback too — Don't wait for feedback to come to you. Ask for it regularly, so you keep learning too.
Activity 1 · 10 mins
Write your script for a difficult conversation
- Choose a real conversation you have coming up where you need to give critical feedback or ask someone to change something.
- Write your script in four parts:
- Micro-yes: a short question that checks whether now is a good time.
- Data point: what you saw or heard, with no blur words.
- Impact statement: how that affected you, your team, or the work.
- Question: an open question that invites their view, such as "How do you see it?"
- Read your draft back and circle any blur words (for example "attitude," "proactive," or "professional"). Replace each one with what you saw or heard.
- Think about what a good outcome would look like. Write down one concrete next step you could suggest, but be open to coming up with a different solution together.
- Look at the moves for defusing defensiveness below. Choose one or two that you might use if the person reacts negatively. You don't need to include these in your script. Just keep them in your back pocket in case the conversation gets difficult.
Here's an example script:
Micro-yes: "Do you have five minutes to talk about the proposal?"
Data point: "You said you'd send the revised version by Tuesday at noon, and I received it Wednesday afternoon."
Impact statement: "Because it came in late, I had one hour to review it before it went to the client."
Question: "What happened on your end?"
Moves for defusing defensiveness
If the other person gets defensive, you don't need to abandon your message or argue with them. Try one of these moves to keep the conversation constructive:
- Acknowledge their view: "Thanks for explaining. I can see where you're coming from."
- Ask an open question: "What do you think would help us avoid this next time?"
- Say back what you heard: "Let me check I've understood what you're saying..."
- Return to the facts: "I hear that. What I saw was..."
- Suggest a pause: "Would it help to take a break and come back to this?"
- Agree on a next step: "What can we agree to do differently next time?"
Optional take-home practice: Paste your script into an AI tool and ask it to flag any blur words and suggest more specific wording. Compare its version with yours and keep what sounds like you. Don't include confidential or identifying details about the other person.
Activity 2 · 15 mins
Practice with a partner
- Split into pairs. If your Circle has an odd number of members, make one group of three. Take turns: one person delivers their script, and the other plays the person receiving it. Give your partner one sentence of context first, such as the person's role and how they usually react.
- The person receiving responds the way the real person might, including getting a little defensive ("That's not fair" or "Nobody told me that"). They might also say "Everyone else does it too" or "I didn't realize that was a problem." The giver uses one of their backup moves if needed, returns to the facts, and works with the other person to agree on a concrete next step.
- Spend about 4 minutes on each role-play, then swap. In groups of three, rotate roles so everyone has a chance to practice giving feedback. After each round, tell the person giving feedback one phrase that worked well and one that could be more specific. If you get stuck, pause and try again.
Discuss as a group:
- What helped you stay clear and defuse defensiveness when the other person pushed back?
- How did you work together to agree on a next step?
One Action · 5 mins
Commit to one concrete action — big or small — you'll take before the next meeting. Go around the Circle and share (1 minute or less per member). Saying it out loud helps hold each other accountable.
Have one feedback conversation using the four-part formula before our next meeting. Come back ready to share how it went.
Wrap-up · 5 mins
Before you break, plan your next meeting and close on an energetic note. Go around your Circle one by one and finish the sentence:
Now I am feeling… (choose one word).
- Set the day, time, and location
- Choose the next topic or resource
- Confirm who's leading the discussion
- Decide how you'll stay in touch in between