How to get better feedback and use it to grow

By Mary Noble-Tolla ·

Before You Start

Goal: Get better at asking for, handling, and acting on feedback so you keep growing and the people around you keep investing in you. Leave with one specific change to try this month.

Watch: Members are encouraged to watch the video beforehand, but a quick recap at the meeting works too. Brought to you in collaboration with Kym Ward Gaffney, Coaching Leader, PwC, and Michael Fenlon, Global Talent Leader, PwC.


Meeting Agenda · Approx. 60 mins

  • Member Updates · 10 mins
  • Icebreaker · 10 mins
  • Key Takeaways · 5 mins
  • Activities · 20 mins
  • One Action · 10 mins
  • Wrap-Up · 5 mins

Member Updates · 10 mins

Go around your Circle and share personal updates. Keep them brief and focused on significant changes or important decisions since the last time you met. It's OK not to have one every month. If you have a One Action update from last time, share that too.


Icebreaker · 10 mins

Invite everyone in the group to share. Keep answers to one or two minutes per person.

In your Circle, share your response to one of the questions below:

  • Whose experience did you connect with in the video, and what messages personally resonated with you?
  • What is your current mindset when receiving feedback, and how can others see this mindset demonstrated in your actions?
  • What recent feedback have you received that was helpful, and how did you use it to grow?

Key Takeaways · 5 mins

Feedback is information that helps you affirm or adjust your performance. It can be a formal or informal conversation, and it may include positive reinforcement or constructive suggestions on how you handled a task or engaged in an activity. We all have blind spots, so being open to feedback, listening to other perspectives, and acting on relevant suggestions helps you grow, deepens your relationships, and shows your commitment to your development. When you ask for feedback and respond to it thoughtfully, others tend to keep investing in you.

Strong feedback habits have three things in common:

  • A growth mindset. You stay open to suggestions, actively ask for other people's perspectives, and stay curious.
  • A two-way dialogue. You set expectations, get ongoing input on your progress, and ask questions.
  • An action orientation. You go beyond saying "thanks." You make sure you understand the feedback, commit to actions, and set up touch points to check your progress.

To get the most from feedback, remain AWARE:

  • Ask for feedback
  • Watch your emotions
  • Ask questions to clarify
  • Reach out for different perspectives
  • Engage your potential

Adapted from PwC's "Focusing on feedback" discussion guide, © 2014 PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, in collaboration with Lean In.


Activity 1 · 10 mins

Personal Inventory

Work on your own for this activity. Be honest with yourself so you can identify your strengths and areas to work on.

Part 1: Focusing on feedback self-reflection profile (2 minutes)

Being AWARE of your current feedback mindset is a good place to start. Circle your response to the questions below.

Ask for feedback

How consistent are you at…1: extremely inconsistent → 5: extremely consistent
Proactively requesting feedback?1 2 3 4 5
Conveying openness to receiving feedback based on your actions?1 2 3 4 5

Watch your emotions

When receiving feedback, how frequently do you…1: never → 5: always
Remain open to what you are hearing?1 2 3 4 5
Ask to "take a moment" if you feel your emotions are getting in the way of hearing the message?1 2 3 4 5

Ask questions to clarify

During a feedback conversation, how frequently do you…1: never → 5: always
Listen to understand, not to respond?1 2 3 4 5
Ask questions and request specific examples to deepen your understanding of what you're hearing?1 2 3 4 5

Reach out for different perspectives

After a feedback conversation, how frequently do you…1: never → 5: always
Ask a trusted friend or colleague to act as a sounding board on the feedback you received?1 2 3 4 5
Self-reflect and search for themes and actionable truths in the message?1 2 3 4 5

Engage your potential

After a feedback conversation, how consistent are you at…1: extremely inconsistent → 5: extremely consistent
Thanking the individual providing you feedback?1 2 3 4 5
Evaluating the feedback and committing to action items?1 2 3 4 5

Part 2, Step 1: Recall a recent feedback experience (about 3 minutes)

Recall a recent feedback experience—either positive or challenging—and answer the questions below. This could be an experience you had with a supervisor, colleague, professor, or coach.

What was the feedback you received? Who was it from? What was the outcome?

Your notes:

 

Part 2, Step 2: Reflect on how AWARE you were (about 5 minutes)

Having a growth mindset and truly listening to other people's perspectives during a feedback conversation are great ways to raise your self-awareness. In order to build the skills needed to remain AWARE when receiving feedback, it's important to reflect upon your mindset and actions during recent feedback conversations.

Reflect on your feedback experience and evaluate how AWARE you were during the interaction.

Personal reflections
Ask for feedbackDid I actively solicit feedback from this individual in advance or did the feedback come as a surprise?
Watch your emotionsDid I have an emotional reaction to the feedback that prevented me from hearing the message? Was I defensive or argumentative? Did I shut down?
Ask questions to clarifyDid I ask questions to make sure I fully understood what was being shared? If "yes," what did I ask? If "no," what held me back?
Reach out for different perspectivesDid I agree with what was being said? If not, did I ask a trusted friend or colleague to provide his/her viewpoint on the feedback that was given?
Engage your potentialWhat actions did I take after receiving the feedback? Did I thank the individual providing me feedback? Did I follow up to discuss my progress?

Activity 2 · 10 mins

Analyzing Your Approach

In your Circle, provide a brief overview of your feedback experience. Then, share your responses to the statements below. Keep your share to about two minutes per person.

When I reflected on my experience using the AWARE framework:

  • My biggest strength was…
  • My biggest challenge was…
  • My biggest takeaway on how I can maximize the impact of feedback was…

Your notes:

 


One Action · 10 mins

Commit to one concrete action — big or small — you'll take before next meeting. Go around the Circle and share (1 minute or less per member). Vocalizing it helps hold each other accountable.

Based on the topics discussed today, identify up to three action items that you will commit to working on as part of your goal of focusing on feedback. Use items from this list or document additional goals in the space below. Share your action commitment with your Circle to help you stay accountable for making a change.

Actions I will take to maximize my feedback opportunities:

Ask for feedback

  • Identify people who can provide me with helpful feedback to grow and develop.
  • Proactively request feedback.
  • Convey a willingness to receive feedback based on my actions.

Watch your emotions

  • Remain open to what I am hearing.
  • Avoid defensive statements or shutting down.
  • Ask to "take a moment" if I feel my emotions are getting in the way of hearing the message.

Ask questions to clarify

  • Listen to understand, not to respond.
  • Ask questions to deepen my understanding of what's being shared.
  • Request specific examples to provide context for observations.

Reach out for different perspectives

  • Remember that what the speaker is sharing is one perspective on my behavior.
  • Ask a trusted friend or colleague to act as a sounding board on what was shared.
  • Search for themes and actionable truths contained in the message so I can outline next steps.

Engage your potential

  • Thank the individual providing me feedback.
  • Evaluate the feedback I've been given and collaborate on next steps I will commit to.
  • Set aside time to follow up and assess my progress.

Other actions I will take to focus on feedback include:

 

Share at your next Circle meeting: What have you done differently?

Ongoing worksheet: Copy this worksheet and use it each time you prepare for an upcoming feedback opportunity.

  • Who should I reach out to for feedback?
  • Are there any specific areas for which I want feedback? If so, what are they?
  • If I have an emotional reaction to what is shared, what techniques might I use to manage my response?
  • Who will serve as my sounding board if I need help making sense of the feedback I received?
  • How will I show gratitude for the investment in my development and my commitment to acting on the feedback I've been given?

Wrap-Up · 5 mins

Before you break, plan your next meeting and close on an energetic note. Go around your Circle one by one and finish the sentence:

Now I am feeling… (choose one word).

  • Set the day, time, and location
  • Choose the next topic or resource
  • Confirm who's leading the discussion
  • Decide how you'll stay in touch in between